ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsNew York › Staten Island

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Staten Island, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Staten Island, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Staten Island, New York is Christine Relyea - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 1,413 reviews. Other highly rated options include NYC Business Group, Alpha Omega Coverage Corp, 5Boroughs Insurance Agency. This directory lists 20 medicare insurance agents serving Staten Island.

Showing 20 medicare insurance agents in Staten Island, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Christine Relyea - State Farm Insurance Agent2391 Richmond Ave(718) 698-5803
2NYC Business Group3971 Victory Blvd(718) 554-3425
3Alpha Omega Coverage Corp1253 Richmond Ave(718) 494-4440
45Boroughs Insurance Agency1110 South Ave(718) 766-8121
5Aleph Insurance Agency, Inc109 New Dorp Plaza(718) 865-8665
6DMAS Insurance1132 Forest Ave(718) 981-0700
7Smart Choice Insurance of NY1931 Richmond Ave(315) 239-1293
8Kraus & Kraus Insurance Agency, Inc.1562 Richmond Rd #202(315) 889-3203
9Fusco Insurance, Retirement & Wealth Planning Services12 Fremont Ave(718) 701-5787
10Fidelis Care - Staten Island Community Office965 Richmond Ave(718) 420-1236
CR
2391 Richmond Ave
Christine Relyea - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

Christine Relyea - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Staten Island, NY area, offering guidance on Medicare insurance options. As a local agency, it helps individuals navigate the enrollment process and understand plan coverage. The agency assists clients with comparing benefits and costs associated with Medicare supplement policies. It also provides support for reviewing Part D prescription drug plans to find suitable coverage. Christine Relyea - State Farm Insurance Agent handles Medicare Advantage plan selections and annual enrollment period changes.

NB
3971 Victory Blvd
NYC Business Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

NYC Business Group provides Medicare insurance guidance to individuals navigating their coverage options in Staten Island, New York. The company assists with plan comparisons, enrollment procedures, and annual review services to ensure policies align with changing healthcare needs. It offers ongoing support for beneficiaries managing their Part D prescription drug plans as well as Medicare Advantage and Medigap policies. Clients in single-family homes, apartment complexes, retail spaces, and restaurants utilize the agency’s services to secure appropriate health coverage for themselves or their employees.

AO
1253 Richmond Ave
Alpha Omega Coverage Corp
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

Alpha Omega Coverage Corp serves Staten Island residents who are navigating their Medicare options, helping them understand Part A, Part B, and supplemental plans. The agency simplifies the enrollment process and annual plan changes for clients approaching eligibility or already on Medicare. It offers personalized guidance to match coverage with individual healthcare needs and budgets. The company also extends its services to clients in the surrounding communities of Brooklyn.

5I
1110 South Ave
5Boroughs Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

5Boroughs Insurance Agency serves clients in Staten Island and the surrounding New York City communities, specializing in Medicare insurance plans. The agency handles both Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement policies for eligible individuals. It also assists with Part D prescription drug coverage and explains the annual enrollment periods clearly. To manage each case, the agency begins by reviewing a client’s current health needs and budget before comparing available plan options side by side.

AI
109 New Dorp Plaza
Aleph Insurance Agency, Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

Aleph Insurance Agency, Inc in Staten Island, NY offers both one-time consultations to clarify initial Medicare enrollment and ongoing service options to adjust coverage as needs change. Coverage comparisons are tailored to each client’s medical and financial situation. The agency reviews plan benefits, prescription drug formularies, and network providers to help clients make informed choices. Service runs on either a scheduled appointment basis or as needed when plan changes, life events, or enrollment periods occur.

DI
1132 Forest Ave
DMAS Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

DMAS Insurance offers Medicare insurance agent services specializing in helping seniors navigate plan options in Staten Island, NY. The practice guides clients through the complexities of Medicare Advantage, Supplement plans, and Part D drug coverage. It works to match individuals with plans that suit their healthcare needs and budgets. Each year during the Annual Enrollment Period, the company assists Staten Island residents in reviewing and updating their existing coverage to avoid gaps or higher costs.

SC
1931 Richmond Ave
Smart Choice Insurance of NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

Smart Choice Insurance of NY provides guidance on Medicare health coverage options for residents of Staten Island and the surrounding area. The company specializes in explaining Medicare Advantage plans, prescription drug coverage, and Medicare Supplement policies available to eligible individuals. Its agents help clients navigate enrollment periods and compare different plan benefits within the local insurance marketplace. The company typically serves people in residential neighborhoods, medical offices, and small retail storefronts across Staten Island.

KK
1562 Richmond Rd #202
Kraus & Kraus Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

Kraus & Kraus Insurance Agency, Inc. provides residential medicare services for individuals on Staten Island, as well as offering commercial coverage for those who are still working and enrolled in employer-sponsored group health plans. The agency serves clients throughout New York City’s five boroughs, navigating the complexities of federal and state health insurance requirements. After an initial enrollment consultation, the same agent typically provides ongoing support for plan changes or renewals between each patient’s routine checkups.

FI
12 Fremont Ave
Fusco Insurance, Retirement & Wealth Planning Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

Fusco Insurance, Retirement & Wealth Planning Services is a Medicare insurance agency based in Staten Island, New York, known for guiding clients through their initial enrollment and annual plan review periods. The agency provides personalized consultations to help individuals compare Part D prescription drug plans, Medicare Advantage options, and Medigap policies available in the area. As an additional specialty service, the agency offers guidance on pairing long-term care insurance solutions with an existing Medicare coverage plan.

FC
965 Richmond Ave
Fidelis Care - Staten Island Community Office
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY

As fall approaches and Medicare open enrollment nears, many Staten Island seniors seek clear guidance on their plan options. Fidelis Care - Staten Island Community Office assists local individuals by offering straightforward consultations to compare Medicare Supplement and Advantage plans. The office is conveniently located in the borough and provides personalized support to those newly eligible or reviewing annual coverage changes. Agents here help clarify plan benefits and potential out-of-pocket costs. An initial assessment is typically conducted by phone or in person to review a client’s current healthcare needs and budget.

PI
3457 Richmond Rd
Public Insurance Agency Co
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(516) 421-6764
AC
653 Forest Ave
Allen C Bentson Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(718) 442-1771
bentsoninsurance.net
AB
32 Richmond Ter
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(888) 809-8009
anthembluecross.com
FI
3951 Amboy Rd
Fund Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(516) 421-6825
PI
1441 Richmond Ave
Preferred Insurance Co
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(315) 236-2599
SI
1842 Hylan Blvd
Support Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(929) 388-0415
TI
1972 Richmond Ter
Term Insurance Co
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(347) 292-7824
MP
238A Port Richmond Ave
MetroPlusHealth, Port Richmond Community Office
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(866) 496-6636
metroplus.org
RA
2052 Richmond Rd
Regency Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(718) 377-0566
regencyagency.com
CI
1110 South Ave #100
Cerverizzo Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Staten Island, NY
(347) 577-9867
cerverizzoagency.com

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Staten Island Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Staten Island typically do not charge you a fee for their services. They earn commissions from the insurance companies. Premium costs for Medicare plans vary widely. For example a Medigap Plan G in New York can cost between 150 and 400 dollars per month depending on your age and location. Part D drug plan premiums average about 30 to 80 dollars per month. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Staten Island

A Medicare insurance agent in Staten Island can help you compare plans and enroll at the right time. New York has specific rules like the guaranteed issue period for Medigap plans. Local agents know the hospitals and doctors in the borough.

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I enroll in Medicare in Staten Island?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before your 65th birthday month and ends three months after. New York also has a special annual enrollment period from January 1 to March 31 each year.

What is the New York Medigap open enrollment rule?

In New York you have a guaranteed issue right for Medigap plans for six months starting when you turn 65 and enroll in Part B. During this time insurers cannot deny you coverage or charge more for health conditions.

Do Medicare agents in Staten Island charge a fee?

Most Medicare insurance agents in New York are paid by insurance companies and do not charge you directly. Always confirm the agent is licensed and ask about any fees before you sign up.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.