Skip to main content

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Buffalo, NY

Directory of supplemental insurance agents in Buffalo, New York. Verify credentials with the state department of insurance before hiring.

20 agents listed
Updated May 2026
Buffalo, NY
Important: Listings are compiled from publicly available sources and have not been independently verified by BeforeInsuranceUSA.com. We do not endorse any agent or guarantee outcomes. Verify licensing and disciplinary status with the Department of Insurance of New York before hiring.
Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Buffalo, NY Listings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked by BeforeInsuranceUSA. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement of any agent.
Willoughby Insurance
1523 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14209
(716) 885-8100 willoughbyinsurance.com
Medicare Management of WNY
8645 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14221
(716) 833-0252 wnymedicare.org
Craig Maitland - GEICO Insurance Agent
3618 Delaware Ave Suite 400, Buffalo, NY 14217
(716) 517-3300 geico.com
Sheridan Benefits
6700 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14221
(716) 580-3773 sheridanbenefits.com
Jody Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency
400 Essjay Rd #300, Buffalo, NY 14221
(716) 809-9169 comparioninsurance.com
Freeway Insurance
1526 Walden Ave Suite 500, Buffalo, NY 14225
(716) 250-9472 locations.freeway.com
Damien Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency
400 Essjay Rd #300, Buffalo, NY 14221
(716) 276-7247 comparioninsurance.com
Lawley
361 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14202
(716) 849-8618 lawleyinsurance.com
New Buffalo Insurance Agency, Inc.
686 Main St Suite 201, Buffalo, NY 14202
(716) 332-1570 newbuffaloinsurance.com
Donna Medina at Comparion Insurance Agency
400 Essjay Rd #300, Buffalo, NY 14221
(716) 730-4909 comparioninsurance.com
Nick Messuro - State Farm Insurance Agent
3407 Delaware Ave Ste 101, Buffalo, NY 14217
(716) 873-6015 insurancebuf.com
Tamaris Lott - State Farm Insurance Agent
2631 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14214
(716) 835-9393 tamarislott.net
Niagara National Insurance
5001 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY 14225
(716) 684-6000 niagaranational.com
Encompass Agency, Inc.
529 French Rd, Buffalo, NY 14227
(716) 835-6790 encompassupstate.com
Walsh Insurance
726 Exchange St Ste 200, Buffalo, NY 14210
(716) 853-3820 walshins.com
NYCM Insurance Agency - Home, Auto & Business
1840 Clinton St, Buffalo, NY 14206
(716) 404-0300 truecutinsurance.com
Clauss & Company Insurance Agency
735 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14209
(716) 886-6600 claussinsurance.com
Amherst Insurance Agency, Inc.
333 International Dr, Buffalo, NY 14221
(716) 580-1200 amherstinsurance.com
Toni DuBois Agency, LLC
1439 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14209
(716) 931-5200 toniduboisagency.com
Hoch Insurance Agency
2333 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
(716) 881-1975 hochinsuranceagency.com

Supplemental insurance agents in Buffalo, New York help residents find policies like Medigap or accident plans to cover gaps in primary health insurance. New York state law guarantees a 30-day free look period for Medicare supplement policies, allowing you to review your purchase without penalty. Agents can explain how local health systems and New York-specific regulations affect your options.

What Does a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Buffalo Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in New York vary by plan type and provider. Medigap Plan G in Buffalo typically ranges from $150 to $300 per month for a 65-year-old, while accident plans may cost $30 to $80 monthly. New York uses community rating for Medigap, meaning premiums do not increase with age. This is general information, not insurance advice.

* Cost estimates are general ranges based on publicly available data and compiled using automated research tools. Actual fees vary by agent and case complexity. This is not insurance advice — consult directly with an agent for fee specifics.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Buffalo?
A supplemental insurance agent in Buffalo helps you find and enroll in policies that cover costs not paid by your primary insurance, such as deductibles or copays. They are licensed in New York and must follow state rules for selling plans like Medicare supplements or hospital indemnity insurance.
Are there New York laws for supplemental insurance agents?
Yes, New York requires agents to be licensed and to follow strict guidelines for Medicare supplement sales. For example, agents cannot sell duplicate coverage and must provide a 30-day free look period for new Medigap policies. These rules protect consumers from unnecessary policies.
How do I choose a supplemental insurance agent in Buffalo?
Look for an agent who is licensed in New York and has experience with local health plans. You can verify their license through the New York State Department of Financial Services. Ask about their knowledge of Buffalo hospitals and networks to ensure your coverage works locally.