ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Rochester, NY

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Rochester, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Rochester, New York is VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC, rated 5.0 stars across 438 reviews. Other highly rated options include Elmwood Agency, Quinton Insurance, Freeway Insurance. This directory lists 51 supplemental insurance agents serving Rochester.

Showing 51 supplemental insurance agents in Rochester, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC1577 W Ridge Rd Suite 218(585) 663-2004
2Elmwood Agency1 Reserve View Blvd(585) 548-4500
3Quinton Insurance2700 Elmwood Ave(585) 244-9004
4Freeway Insurance2199 E Henrietta Rd(585) 283-2053
5FLANAGAN MILLS INSURANCE AGENCY448 Titus Ave(585) 678-8008
6Flour City Insurance Agency1260 Scottsville Rd Suite 202A(585) 861-2002
7Insurance Marketplace Agency150 Allens Creek Rd Suite 220(585) 482-9980
8InsuranceTrak Services4515 Culver Rd # 206(585) 282-0934
9Ferris Insurance Agency2314 Lyell Ave(585) 254-7440
10Lifetime Financial Group, LLC35 State St(585) 325-2525
VI
1577 W Ridge Rd Suite 218
VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

VanScoter Insurance Agency LLC, based in Rochester, New York, assists clients with general supplemental insurance coverage designed to fill gaps left by major medical plans, including accident and critical illness policies. The agency’s specialty add-ons allow individuals to address specific financial exposures that standard health insurance does not cover. These customizable solutions provide support during unexpected health events, ensuring a smoother recovery process. The agency serves a diverse range of commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments, tailoring coverage to meet workplace-specific needs.

EA
1 Reserve View Blvd
Elmwood Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

The long winters in Rochester often prompt families to review their protection plans, and Elmwood Agency helps residents navigate supplemental insurance options to fill gaps in standard health coverage. As a nearby agency, it focuses on explaining plan differences without assuming prior knowledge of the field. The typical process begins with an inspection-style review of current policies and household needs, starting with a simple initial-assessment phone call to identify the right area of coverage.

QI
2700 Elmwood Ave
Quinton Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Based in Rochester, New York, Quinton Insurance works as a Supplemental Insurance Agent to help clients bridge gaps in standard coverage. The company specializes in offering secondary policies that provide added financial protection for unexpected events not fully covered by primary plans. These supplemental products help manage out-of-pocket costs and offer additional security for individuals and businesses. Quinton Insurance serves a variety of commercial sectors, including local offices, warehouses, and food service operations requiring tailored coverage solutions.

FI
2199 E Henrietta Rd
Freeway Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Freeway Insurance serves residents of Rochester, New York, providing supplemental insurance coverage to help fill gaps in primary health plans. The agency also assists local businesses with commercial policies designed to protect their operations and employees. Service extends throughout the Rochester area, offering tailored options for individuals and organizations. Clients often contact the agency between regular visits to adjust their coverage as their needs change, ensuring ongoing protection.

FM
448 Titus Ave
FLANAGAN MILLS INSURANCE AGENCY
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

FLANAGAN MILLS INSURANCE AGENCY is a Supplemental Insurance Agent company serving clients in Rochester, New York. This agency helps individuals fill gaps in their primary health coverage by offering policies that cover deductibles, copays, and other out-of-pocket costs. Such supplemental plans are designed to provide financial protection against unexpected medical expenses. The agency also specializes in enrolling clients in short-term medical plans to bridge coverage between job changes or other life transitions.

FC
1260 Scottsville Rd Suite 202A
Flour City Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Flour City Insurance Agency serves the Rochester, New York metro area by helping residents and families navigate the complexities of supplemental health coverage. Supplemental insurance agents in this region typically address gaps left by primary medical and hospital plans. The agency focuses on policies that provide additional financial protection for unexpected medical events and everyday healthcare expenses. These offerings often include critical illness coverage and hospital indemnity plans, which help policyholders manage out-of-pocket costs not covered by major medical insurance.

IM
150 Allens Creek Rd Suite 220
Insurance Marketplace Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Insurance Marketplace Agency provides a range of supplemental insurance options to help clients manage out-of-pocket costs not covered by major medical plans. Its service approach focuses on guiding individuals through plan selection and assisting with claims and policy questions. These plans help cover expenses like deductibles, copays, and other gaps. The agency services a variety of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants in the Rochester, New York, area.

IS
4515 Culver Rd # 206
InsuranceTrak Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
FI
2314 Lyell Ave
Ferris Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY

Ferris Insurance Agency serves homeowners, small businesses, and property managers in Rochester, New York, who need supplemental coverage beyond standard policies. The agency assists clients with selecting accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans that help fill gaps left by major medical insurance. Each policy option is explained with attention to individual risk situations and budget constraints. Licensed agents guide customers through enrollment and ongoing claims support. The agency also provides coverage assistance for residents in the nearby town of Irondequoit.

LF
35 State St
Lifetime Financial Group, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
TC
919 S Winton Rd #210
Twelve Corners Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 789-6488
12cornersinsurance.com
FI
1038 Lyell Ave
Farmers Insurance - Miriam Rivera
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 360-0094
agents.farmers.com/ny/rochester/1555040-miriam-rivera
WI
200 Winton Rd
Woodbury Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 288-4901
agents.allstate.com/woodbury-insurance-agency-rochester-ny.html
CB
400 White Spruce Blvd suite c
Century Benefits Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 224-8138
centurybenefitsgroup.com
RG
1100 Long Pond Rd Suite 100
Rochester Group Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 794-5640
rochestergroupinc.com
VA
849 Paul Rd Ste 220
Vail Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 889-4650
vail-insurance.com
PI
1815 S Clinton Ave Building 400 Suite 435
Paradigm Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 623-1550
paradigmnyinsurance.com/index.html#hero
BA
333 Metro Park Suite S202
The Belmont Agency Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 571-7006
belmontagencyllc.com
MI
1619 East Ridge Road
Mazzola Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 266-7130
mazzolainsurance.org
RI
4424 Lyell Rd
Ridgecrest Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 287-5490
erieinsurance.com/agencies/nn2708
MP
530 Titus Ave
M-Power Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 678-8844
m-poweragency.com
CB
70 Linden Oaks #300
Clear Benefits Advisors | Medicare EASY!
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 299-2199
clearbenefitsadvisors.com
CI
1200 Jefferson Rd Suite 100-A
Comparion Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 424-6050
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/rochester-0825
LA
441 East Ave
Lawley
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 454-1600
lawleyinsurance.com/locations/rochester-insurance
CE
900 Jefferson Rd
Century Enrollment & Benefit Services, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 507-9517
centuryadvisory.com
TA
1880 East Ridge Road Uppr 5
Trovato Associates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 563-6553
trovatoassociates.com
EB
165 Court St
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 454-1700
excellusbcbs.com
CA
1819 East Ridge Road
Consolidated Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 467-4110
consolidatedagencyinc.com
BR
4072 W Henrietta Rd
Beth Rogers Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 321-0015
bethrogersagency.com
NI
95 Allens Creek Rd Ste 1316
Nationwide Insurance: Karen Bortnick Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 271-7683
agency.nationwide.com/ny/rochester/14618/karen-bortnick-agency
ML
1225 Jefferson Rd Suite A03
Maust and Leone
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 563-7979
maustandleone.com
AB
2800 Dewey Ave
Ahrens Benefits Company
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 601-5000
ahrensbenefitsco.com
SG
3445 Winton Pl #109
The Schultz Group of NY
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 424-1780
schultzgroupofny.com
SS
306 John St
Super Senior Services Incorporated
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 802-2635
superseniorservices.com
BI
69 Empire Blvd
Bobby Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 288-2741
MJ
120 Corporate Woods
Marks Jerome M Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 475-0220
marksagency.com
UI
1134 Titus Ave
Urbanski Insurance Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 467-1129
mercuryinsurance.com/agents/new-york/urbanski-insurance-311106.html
OS
1400 Portland Ave Ste. 24
ortolani services inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 242-9749
ortservices.com
TG
4124 W Henrietta Rd
Tom Gervais - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 359-4280
tomgervaisagency.com
PI
3255 Brighton Henrietta Town Line Rd
Pinnacle Insurance Agency Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 235-6070
pinnacleinsurance.net
PI
1230 - 1260 Lyell Ave
Private Insurance NY
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 902-2563
YM
1225 Jefferson Rd Suite A03
Your Medicare Solutions Advisor
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 563-7979
BI
3565 Latta Rd
Butler Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 392-8006
butlerinsurance.org
BM
39 Saginaw Dr
Brendan McCarthy - Aflac Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(877) 895-8423
local.aflac.com/brendan_mccarthy/Agent
AI
801 W Main St
Affordable Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(917) 341-4142
LR
2000 S Winton Rd
Lawley ROC Insurance Services, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 413-0483
rocinsuranceservices.com
II
2509 Browncroft Blvd Suite 105
Isaac Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 271-3294
theisaacagency.com
NM
The Legend Group, 1425 Jefferson Rd
NY Medicare Specialists
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 568-2273
nymedicarespecialists.com
SI
1819 Ridge Rd
Skalny Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 254-2118
HH
Buckman's Plaza, 2590 W Ridge Rd Suite 10
Heart and Home Health
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 340-7181
lenadeluca.com
YM
2024 W Henrietta Rd Bldg 2A
Your Medicare Advisers
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Rochester, NY
(585) 354-1915

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Rochester Cost?

The cost of working with a supplemental insurance agent in New York is typically free to you because the agent earns a commission from the insurance company. Plan premiums vary widely: a Medigap Plan G in Rochester can range from $150 to $300 per month for a 65-year-old, while a cancer policy might cost $30 to $80 per month. Costs depend on your age, health, and the specific policy. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Rochester

Supplemental insurance agents in Rochester, New York help residents fill gaps in their primary health coverage. These agents can explain plans like Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and fixed-benefit policies that comply with New York Insurance Law. Local agents understand the unique needs of the Rochester community, including coverage for seasonal workers and retirees.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Rochester?

A supplemental insurance agent in Rochester helps you buy policies that pay cash benefits for specific events, such as hospital stays or critical illness. These plans are separate from major medical insurance and are regulated by the New York State Department of Financial Services.

Do I need a supplemental insurance agent if I have Medicare in New York?

It can be helpful because New York has special rules for Medigap. For example, under New York law, you have a guaranteed issue right to buy a Medigap policy during your initial enrollment period. An agent can compare plans from different carriers to find one that fits your budget.

How do I choose a supplemental insurance agent in Rochester?

Look for an agent licensed by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Ask about their experience with plans like hospital indemnity or accident insurance. Check online reviews and confirm they represent multiple insurance companies to offer you options.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.